Jul 23, 2011
Imara

Propaganda and the Power of Words

One thing I might never have expected to be reinforced by my travels across China was my understanding of the importance of language and definitions.  Particularly in propaganda or other materials meant to motivate and influence the tides of public discourse.  Visiting varied museums on China’s modern history I found myself surprised time and again to see references to democracy among the praises of what the CCP brought to the populace.

As a graduate student, there are constant reminders of the influence words have on people and the difficulties of definitions contrasted with connotations.  Democracy, much like freedom, is a word heavy with emotion but light on definitive meaning.  Scholars of government regularly seek to set rigid definitions these terms to suit the purposes of their studies, even as politicians casually toss them about in attempt to enflame public passions.  Unfortunately outside of academia, the definition of a word means a good deal less than what it is understood and broadly accepted to mean.

This discussion of definition and meaning struck me as particularly relevant in relation to China’s approach to public information and discourse.  Visiting these varied museums across China and reading the depictions of modern Chinese history bluntly displayed the impact of controlling the political narrative.  Ultimately educating the populace on historic events from a single point of view makes that point of view a reality regardless of potential inaccuracies.

One of the things I’ve found myself most appreciative of on this journey is the way that exposure to China has made me question more of my own understandings of the world as an American.  These museum visits called me to question what I’ve been taught of modern history from the point of view of the United States, while at the same time casting recent issues in the United States in a different light.  The battles being waged over the material to be included in history books in a way are battles to determine the future of US public discourse, however unimportant they might seem these are some of the most critical current political conflicts.

2 Comments

  • I think everone who steps off a beach in a foreighn country has their eyes openede; for some its abruptly, for others slowly.

    You seem to cast politicians as manipulators but I would differ. The word “democracy” is a construct or at best a poorly defined word which has been inconsistent throughout time. Therefore it is free to use and misuse at will.

  • While this is certainly not my first time on a foreign beach, it is my first time traveling with the express intent of exploring how a society works rather than just observing foreign culture and enjoying myself. So far my time in China has definitely been enlightening and “eye opening” but at least in part I think that’s due to what I’ve chosen to seek out and learn from during my time here. On your second point we definitely disagree though, and I guess that was the point of this post. Words have meaning, the reality that those meanings change with time doesn’t make them any less important/relevant. In political language, I would argue that the connotation and public understanding of a word matters much more than any definition could, and that at bare minimum people might understand “democracy” as an ability to chose representatives who will support your interests. You’re right broadly on my opinion of politicians, but I guess that wasn’t really my point here.

Leave a comment

Founded in 2004, Democracy and Society is a biannual print journal published by the Center for Democracy and Civil Society at Georgetown University. The D&S Blog provides web-only content, including special reports and investigative series, on issues relating to democracy and development.

Sign up for our mailing list

Posts by Region

Posts by Topic

Switch to our mobile site